One day after Prime Video announced the cancellation of "It’s Not Like That," the show's lead actor and producer Scott Foley shared his reaction to the decision on Instagram. Foley noted that the series had been on Prime Video's Top 10 list for six weeks and had reached as high as third place. He expressed that this was a significant achievement for him, stating he was disappointed but still grateful.

Foley emphasized that the show received strong reviews and positive feedback from viewers. He mentioned that projects like this, especially those with faith-themed stories, have the potential to create an emotional connection with audiences. He said the cancellation decision was a tough situation for him and the team. The series "It’s Not Like That" had managed to reach many viewers by addressing family values and themes of faith.

Following the cancellation, Foley expressed his appreciation for the team's efforts and his commitment to the project. He noted that thanks to the support and interest of viewers, the show quickly built a large fanbase, and he hoped that such productions would continue to exist in the future. Although the cancellation was an unexpected development for both the cast and the audience, Foley's positive attitude stood out.