Some games never end. Years after a childhood friend's disastrous séance leads to her disappearance, a psychologist is forced to confront her past when another young girl goes missing. When Joni was 14, her best friend Gracie Darling vanished during a séance. Nearly 27 years later, the children of a small town entertain themselves with the game "Playing Gracie Darling"; however, this seemingly innocent game takes a terrifying turn with the disappearance of another girl. Joni, who was a child psychologist at the time, returns to the town and collaborates with Police Sergeant Jay to uncover the truth. Gracie's sister Ruth faces a mother's worst nightmare when her own daughter goes missing under similar circumstances.