Red Dead Redemption 2 is an incredibly impressive game for many fans. Its open world has been made interesting and vibrant in a way that many studios (even AAA developers) cannot replicate. Rockstar achieved this success not only through budget but also by creating unique events and injecting personality to add depth to the game's world.

For this reason, fans are reluctant to move to a third game with a new gang. The main characters from the second game are so memorable that it will be hard to accept anyone else. As with open world projects, there is a divide among fans, especially on platforms like Reddit. Before Grand Theft Auto 6 is released, it's the right time to think about what the third game will be like.

Reddit user Different-Complex933 presented a new game idea that sparked discussions among fans. The user said, "I had a dream last night that I was playing Red Dead Redemption 3, and it was very vivid. I was playing as Lyle Morgan and was part of the Jack Hall Gang. In some chapters, I was also playing with a second character named Edmund, who had a structure similar to Hosea's character."

Fans listening to this concept are divided. One group wants to see something completely different, while the other group supports this idea. Some fans suggest that Red Dead 3 should focus on the formation of the Van der Linde gang and Arthur's growth. Regardless, there is great anticipation for which time period Red Dead Redemption 3 will take place in and when it will be announced.