Stacey and Debbie trap their intended date for the dance, Jonas, in a revealing game of Truth or Dare, and Liz tries to rope her sister's boyfriend Kyle into the game. Stan unexpectedly comes back from San Francisco a day early, and finds his girlfriend Sally interviewing her boyfriend from elementary school, Chuckie. Dean has a co-ed bathroom romance going with Claire, but he's frightened of their growing intimacy because he's still a virgin.
